THEBEAUTY READ
ArticlesSkincareSuncareMakeupHairBodyBeauty ToolsBeauty IntelligenceFragrance
Explore reviews ↗
Menu ☰
ArticlesSkincareSuncareMakeupHairBodyBeauty ToolsBeauty IntelligenceFragrance
Home
›
Articles
›
Maybelline Serum Lipstick Review: 8 in 10 Ulta Reviewers Got It Free
November 17, 2026

Maybelline Serum Lipstick Review: 8 in 10 Ulta Reviewers Got It Free

IN THIS REVIEWThe quick takeCompare the optionsSources & limitsHow we review

THE BEAUTY READ / FIND YOUR FIT

The decision, simplified.

Is maybelline serum lipstick long lasting? What 27 reviews without a free-product note and 169 for Super Stay Matte Ink said about wear and moisture.

By THE BEAUTY READ · 7 min read
Review-analysis guide: 394 reviews read on Ulta and Target

Published Nov 17, 2026 · Listings checked November 17, 2026

AI-generated photo: desk sticky notes reading A: 8/27 long wear, B: 62% long wear, A: 7/27 moisturizing, B: 5% moisturizing; plain unlabeled lipstick tubes.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Buttons marked “paid link” go to Amazon and may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Quick picks

For comfort and moisture

Maybelline Serum Lipstick

7/27 kept reviews called it moisturizing; 8 praised the wear, against 62% for Matte Ink

Check price on Amazon ↗ (paid link)

For long wear

Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick

62% of 169 Ulta reviews praised the wear; 19% said sticky or greasy, 12% patchy

Check price on Amazon ↗ (paid link)

Maybelline Serum Lipstick: Sold by Amazon.com at our check; Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick: Seller not confirmed at our check (November 17, 2026). Offers change, so check the name, size and seller on Amazon before you order. The reasons behind each pick are below.

THE BEAUTY READ · REVIEW ANALYSIS

What reviewers said about wear, moisture, transfer, texture and shades

Ulta and Target · November 17, 2026

Where we read, how many and when
RetailerReviews readWhich onesRead on
Ulta · Maybelline Serum Lipstick99every review on the page, 433 when read, January 20, 2026 to November 11, 2026; all written on Ulta; the 99 without the free-product note readNovember 17, 2026
Target · Maybelline Serum Lipstick with Hyaluronic Acid13the newest 408 reviews, November 15, 2025 to October 21, 2026November 17, 2026
Ulta · Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick282the Reviewed at Ulta.com view, January 1, 2024 to November 15, 2026November 17, 2026

Where we read, how many and when

RetailerUlta · Maybelline Serum LipstickTarget · Maybelline Serum Lipstick with Hyaluronic Acid
Reviews read9913
Which onesevery review on the page, 433 when read, January 20, 2026 to November 11, 2026; all written on Ulta; the 99 without the free-product note readthe newest 408 reviews, November 15, 2025 to October 21, 2026
Read onNovember 17, 2026November 17, 2026
RetailerUlta · Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
Reviews read282
Which onesthe Reviewed at Ulta.com view, January 1, 2024 to November 15, 2026
Read onNovember 17, 2026

How we sorted them: the points this review leans on, as reviewers described them: long wear, wore off fast, did not transfer or transferred, moisturizing or comfortable, drying, sticky or greasy, patchy or flaky, and shade praise or shade problems; matte or satin shade, lip liner or balm use, skin tone, mature lips and comparisons with other lipsticks come only from what each reviewer wrote.

Left out of the count: reviews with Ulta's note that the product was received in exchange for an honest review, and the reviews Maybelline's own sites shared to Target's page (counted by stars, not read); reviews that say the lipstick was free or a sample, repeats, reviews about shipping or the store, not used yet or not in English; reviews posted in a month when more than half of a page's 20 or more reviews were free products (Serum Lipstick on Ulta, January to March 2026; Matte Ink, June and July 2025) (60 that said in their own words the lipstick was free or a sample, 16 repeats, about shipping or the store, not used yet or not in English, 122 posted in months when most reviews were free (Serum Lipstick on Ulta, January to March 2026: 56; Matte Ink, June and July 2025: 66)).

Reviews kept per lipstick: Serum Lipstick (27 reviews); Super Stay Matte Ink (169 reviews)

WHO SHOULD SKIP IT

  • You need color that lasts through meals. Maybelline suggests touching up the Serum Lipstick after eating; 8 of 27 reviewers praised its wear, against 62% for Matte Ink.
  • You want a transfer-proof lipstick. Maybelline's own FAQ says the Serum Lipstick is not transfer-proof; it sells Super Stay Matte Ink as the transfer-proof one.
  • You hate sticky liquid mattes (skip Matte Ink). That is Matte Ink's weak spot: 19% of its reviewers said sticky or greasy, against one of 27 for the Serum Lipstick.

MOST OFTEN PRAISED

  • Long wear Serum Lipstick 8 of 27; Matte Ink 62% (105 of 169): Serum Lipstick reviews from January to March 2026: 14 of 56
  • Moisturizing or comfortable Serum Lipstick 7 of 27; Matte Ink 5% (8 of 169): Serum Lipstick reviews from January to March 2026: 31 of 56
  • Shade praise Serum Lipstick 12 of 27; Matte Ink 34% (57 of 169): the top praise for the Serum Lipstick

MOST COMMON COMPLAINTS

  • Sticky or patchy Matte Ink 25% (43 of 169); Serum Lipstick 1 of 27: drying was about even: Matte Ink 11%, Serum Lipstick 2 of 27
  • Wore off fast Serum Lipstick 3 of 27; Matte Ink 9% (15 of 169): about the same share
  • Shade problem Serum Lipstick 5 of 27; Matte Ink 9% (16 of 169): such as a wrong undertone or too few shades for them
  • One or two stars Serum Lipstick 5 of 27; Matte Ink 22% (38 of 169): Serum Lipstick's 358 free-product reviews on Ulta: 1

Where reviews split: Wear and comfort split them. Eight of 27 Serum Lipstick reviewers praised the wear against 62% for Matte Ink, while seven called the Serum Lipstick moisturizing or comfortable against 5% for Matte Ink.

Where reviews split: Sticky and patchy complaints were Matte Ink's. Of its 169 reviewers, 25% said it felt sticky or went patchy, against one of the 27 Serum Lipstick reviewers; drying came up at similar rates.

How reviewers used it: In the reviewer's own words (Serum Lipstick 27 / Matte Ink 169): named a matte Serum Lipstick shade 3/-, a satin one 6/-, wears it with a liner, gloss or balm 1/9, fair skin 1/3, mature lips 1/3, compared it with another lip product 0/8.

Feel, per reviewers: Serum Lipstick (7 of 27 moisturizing; 6 of 27 smooth application); Super Stay Matte Ink (62% (105 of 169) long wear; 13% no transfer) · Scent: Maybelline's FAQ says the Serum Lipstick has a slight vanilla scent, and Maybelline lists fragrance for both lipsticks. None of the 27 Serum Lipstick reviewers we kept complained about the smell or taste, against two of 169 for Matte Ink. Reviewers who mention scent: 2 (0 liked it, 2 did not; both Matte Ink)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

MAKEUP · COMPARISON

Serum Lipstick (27 reviews kept, Ulta from April 2026 and Target): 7 moisturizing, 8 long wear, 12 shade praise; 3 wore off fast, 5 shade problems; 5 one or two stars. Super Stay Matte Ink (169 Ulta reviews, 2024 to 2026): 62% long wear, 13% no transfer; 19% sticky or greasy, 12% patchy, 11% drying; 22% one or two stars.

Maybelline Serum Lipstick and Super Stay Matte Ink | Ulta's Serum Lipstick page (433 reviews), Target's (408 loaded) and the 579 Matte Ink reviews written at Ulta since 2024, 394 read after free-product and Maybelline-site reviews were set aside and 196 kept, January 2024 to November 2026, read November 17, 2026 · product pages checked November 17, 2026

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links marked “paid link” go to Amazon and may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Offers and sellers can change.

The new moisturizing bullet and the long-wear liquid matte

THE BEAUTY READ01

Maybelline Serum Lipstick

FOR COMFORT AND MOISTURE

Comfortable, not a long-wear formula

7/27kept reviews called it moisturizing; 8 praised the wear, against 62% for Matte Ink [5] [6]

You want comfort over wear; 7 of 27 called it moisturizing.

The trade-offNot long-wear; 8 of 27 praised wear vs 62%.

See it on Amazon · paid link ↗Compare ↓

Sold by Amazon.com at our check
November 17, 2026

THE BEAUTY READ02

Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick

FOR LONG WEAR

Long wear, with sticky and patchy notes

62%of 169 Ulta reviews praised the wear; 19% said sticky or greasy, 12% patchy [7]

You need wear; 62% of 169 praised it.

The trade-offTack; 19% sticky, 12% patchy.

See it on Amazon · paid link ↗Compare ↓

Seller not confirmed at our check
November 17, 2026

Compare both Serum Lipstick and Matte Ink side by side ↓

THE BEAUTY READ · EDITOR'S GUIDE

Find the fit for your routine.

A quick editorial read before the deeper review: start with your main concern, then check the evidence, routine fit and trade-offs below.

01

Quick verdict

Serum Lipstick (27 reviews kept, Ulta from April 2026 and Target): 7 moisturizing, 8 long wear, 12 shade praise; 3 wore off fast, 5 shade problems; 5 one or two stars. Super Stay Matte Ink (169 Ulta reviews, 2024 to 2026): 62% long wear, 13% no transfer; 19% sticky or greasy, 12% patchy, 11% drying; 22% one or two stars.

02

Best for

Shoppers deciding between Maybelline's new moisturizing Serum Lipstick and its long-wear Super Stay Matte Ink who want to know what reviewers said once free-product reviews were set aside.

03

Trade-off

The Serum Lipstick gives up wear. Eight of 27 reviewers praised how long it lasted, against 62% for Super Stay Matte Ink, and Maybelline itself says it is not transfer-proof.

04

Think twice

You need color through meals (Maybelline suggests touching up the Serum Lipstick after eating, and 8 of 27 praised its wear). You want a transfer-proof lipstick (Maybelline's FAQ says the Serum Lipstick is not).

THE BEAUTY READ TAKE

Pick the Serum Lipstick if comfort matters more than all-day wear and you are fine touching up after meals; its record is short, 27 reviews once free products were set aside. Pick Super Stay Matte Ink for wear, but expect some tack; 25% of its reviewers said sticky or patchy.

THE COMPARISON / RESEARCH-LED

Side by side, without the noise.

Compare each option’s role and limitations before deciding what belongs in your routine.

Serum Lipstick and Super Stay Matte Ink side by side: formula, wear claim and the link status

Two Maybelline lipsticks. Claims, shades and sizes follow the Ulta and Maybelline pages; the review counts are ours.

Formula and wear claim as Maybelline and Ulta list them, plus the Amazon link status · Links checked November 17, 2026
Product / Amazon linkPick it forWhat it isChoose it ifWatch out forOption we link
Maybelline Serum Lipstick
View on Amazon · paid link ↗
For comfort and moistureBullet lipstick with hyaluronic acid and an oil blend; 8 matte and 8 satin shades (Maybelline)
0.12 oz · 16 shades · not transfer-proof (Maybelline FAQ)
You want comfort over wear; 7 of 27 called it moisturizing.Not long-wear; 8 of 27 praised wear vs 62%.Upstate (satin), 0.12 oz on Ulta; 16 shades, 8 matte and 8 satin (Maybelline); the Amazon number we link is titled 'MAYBELLINE Serum Lipstick ... Upstate (Light Cool Brown Satin)'
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
View on Amazon · paid link ↗
For long wearLiquid matte lipstick with an arrow-tip applicator; transfer-proof, up to 16 hours (Maybelline)
0.17 oz on Ulta · Ulta reviews since 2024 read
You need wear; 62% of 169 praised it.Tack; 19% sticky, 12% patchy.Pioneer, 0.17 oz on Ulta; the Amazon number we link is titled 'Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick Makeup, Pioneer'
Seller not confirmed at our check; we re-check when the listing page is readable.

Formula and wear claim as Maybelline and Ulta list them, plus the Amazon link status · Links checked November 17, 2026

Product / Amazon linkMaybelline Serum LipstickMaybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
Pick it forFor comfort and moistureFor long wear
What it isBullet lipstick with hyaluronic acid and an oil blend; 8 matte and 8 satin shades (Maybelline)
0.12 oz · 16 shades · not transfer-proof (Maybelline FAQ)
Liquid matte lipstick with an arrow-tip applicator; transfer-proof, up to 16 hours (Maybelline)
0.17 oz on Ulta · Ulta reviews since 2024 read
Choose it ifYou want comfort over wear; 7 of 27 called it moisturizing.You need wear; 62% of 169 praised it.
Watch out forNot long-wear; 8 of 27 praised wear vs 62%.Tack; 19% sticky, 12% patchy.
Option we linkUpstate (satin), 0.12 oz on Ulta; 16 shades, 8 matte and 8 satin (Maybelline); the Amazon number we link is titled 'MAYBELLINE Serum Lipstick ... Upstate (Light Cool Brown Satin)'
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
Pioneer, 0.17 oz on Ulta; the Amazon number we link is titled 'Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick Makeup, Pioneer'
Seller not confirmed at our check; we re-check when the listing page is readable.
View on Amazon ↗
(paid link)
View on Amazon ↗
(paid link)
AI-generated photo: desk sticky notes reading A: 8/27 long wear, B: 62% long wear, A: 7/27 moisturizing, B: 5% moisturizing; plain unlabeled lipstick tubes.
THE LINEUP · AT A GLANCE

What changes from one option to the next?

Use this as the fast filter. The full review below explains the evidence, texture, routine fit and trade-offs behind the recommendation.

BEST FOR

Shoppers deciding between Maybelline's new moisturizing Serum Lipstick and its long-wear Super Stay Matte Ink who want to know what reviewers said once free-product reviews were set aside.

TEXTURE

Two Maybelline lipsticks: the new Serum Lipstick, a moisturizing bullet in satin and matte shades, and Super Stay Matte Ink, a long-wear liquid matte

FEELS LIKE

TBR
ROUTINE FIT · BEFORE YOU BUY

Make sure it fits the routine you already have.

The most useful product is not the one with the loudest ingredient story. It is the one you can use consistently without creating unnecessary overlap.

REVIEW SIGNAL

Review-based guide: we read 394 customer reviews on Ulta and Target (November 17, 2026) and tallied the patterns ourselves; product facts come from the Ulta and Maybelline listings.

BIGGEST STRENGTH

Comfort. Seven of the 27 Serum Lipstick reviews we kept called it moisturizing or comfortable, against 5% for Matte Ink, and three complained of a greasy look, patchiness or dryness.

WATCH FOR

The Serum Lipstick gives up wear. Eight of 27 reviewers praised how long it lasted, against 62% for Super Stay Matte Ink, and Maybelline itself says it is not transfer-proof.

TBR ROUTINE NOTE

Check the exact version, label and directions. Your sensitivities, daily setting and existing routine can change the practical fit.

EDITORIAL STANDARD

Our verdict separates recurring user experience from ingredient theory and marketing claims.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links marked “paid link” earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never decide which product we recommend. Offers and sellers change, so check the name, shade and seller on the product page before you buy.

Review-analysis guide: 394 customer reviews read on Ulta and Target (November 17, 2026), sorted and counted by us; product details from the Ulta and Maybelline listings checked November 17, 2026.

By The Beauty Read · Checked November 17, 2026 · AI-assisted research and editing · Contains Amazon affiliate links

This maybelline serum lipstick review starts with Ulta's page, where 358 of the 433 reviews came from shoppers who got the lipstick free. Of the 27 reviews we kept from Ulta and Target without that, seven praised the moisture and eight the wear, while 62% of 169 Ulta reviews praised the wear of Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink (paid link).

Maybelline Serum Lipstick review: what Maybelline launched

This maybelline serum lipstick review covers Maybelline's Serum Lipstick (paid link), a hydrating lipstick with hyaluronic acid and an oil blend in 16 shades, eight matte and eight satin, at 0.12 oz. Maybelline promises up to 35% more hydration instantly and 8 hours of plumping moisture. [2] [1]

Maybelline's own FAQ says the Serum Lipstick is not transfer-proof but is made to resist feathering, and it suggests touching up after eating or after eight hours. It also notes a slight vanilla scent, and Maybelline's ingredient list includes fragrance. [2]

The benchmark is Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink, the brand's liquid matte lipstick with an arrow-tip applicator. Maybelline sells it as transfer-proof with up to 16 hours of wear, and its Ulta page held 18,899 reviews when we read it. [4] [3] [7]

Serum Lipstick is new. Target's page shows reviews shared from Maybelline's site from November 2025, and its first Ulta review is dated January 20, 2026. [6] [5]

Maybelline Serum Lipstick review: 358 of 433 Ulta reviewers got it free

Ulta marks a review when the writer received the product in exchange for an honest review. On the Serum Lipstick page, 334 of the 433 reviews carried that note, and another 24 said in their own words that the lipstick was free or a sample. [5]

None of the 334 marked reviews gave one or two stars, and just one of the other 24 did. Of the 75 left, seven did. [5]

Timing tells the rest. Nine in ten of the 433 reviews (394) were posted from January to March 2026, including 71 on January 20 alone, and 336 of them were for free product. [5]

Our rule sets aside any month with 20 or more reviews on a page when more than half were free products, so January to March 2026 is out of the comparison. That leaves 16 Ulta reviews from April on. [5]

Target's page tells a similar story. It loaded the newest 408 of its 470 reviews, and 395 of those were shared from Maybelline's own sites, 385 with a note that they were collected in a promotion. We read the 13 written at Target and kept 11. [6]

Super Stay Matte Ink had its own free wave. Of the 579 reviews written at Ulta since 2024, 297 carried Ulta's note, 263 of them from June 2025, so June and July 2025 are out too, which left 169. [7]

Is Maybelline Serum Lipstick long lasting? What reviewers said about wear

Wear is where the two are furthest apart. Of the 27 Serum Lipstick reviews we kept, eight praised how long it lasted, against 62% (105 of 169) for Super Stay Matte Ink. [5] [6] [7]

Wearing off fast came up about equally, for 3 of 27 Serum Lipstick reviewers and 9% of Matte Ink reviewers. So does Maybelline Serum Lipstick last? Maybelline itself suggests touching up after meals, and about three in ten of the reviewers we kept praised the wear. [5] [6] [7] [2]

Even the launch-wave reviews agree. Of the 56 Serum Lipstick reviews from January to March 2026 without a free note, 14 praised the wear, about the same share, though they praised the moisture and color payoff far more. [5]

Bar chart of THE BEAUTY READ's counts from Ulta and Target reviews of two Maybelline lipsticks. The new Serum Lipstick has 27 reviews without a free-product note, from Ulta since April 2026 and from Target; each review moves its bars about 4 points. Super Stay Matte Ink has 169 written on Ulta, 2024 to 2026. Praised. Long wear: Serum Lipstick 30%, Matte Ink 62%. Moisturizing or comfortable: Serum Lipstick 26%, Matte Ink 5%. Shade praise: Serum Lipstick 44%, Matte Ink 34%. Smooth application: Serum Lipstick 22%, Matte Ink 7%. No transfer: Serum Lipstick 4%, Matte Ink 13%. Complaints. Wore off fast: Serum Lipstick 11%, Matte Ink 9%. Sticky or greasy: Serum Lipstick 4%, Matte Ink 19%. Patchy or flaky: Serum Lipstick 0%, Matte Ink 12%. Drying: Serum Lipstick 7%, Matte Ink 11%. Shade problem: Serum Lipstick 19%, Matte Ink 9%.
THE BEAUTY READ's own tally: 27 Serum Lipstick reviews (16 from Ulta since April 2026 and 11 written at Target) and 169 Super Stay Matte Ink reviews written on Ulta since 2024. Free-product reviews, Maybelline-site reviews on Target, the months when most reviews were free, and repeats were set aside. With 27 Serum Lipstick reviews, each one moves its bars about 4 points.

Is Maybelline Serum Lipstick transfer proof?

No, by Maybelline's own FAQ, which says it is not transfer-proof. Reviewers rarely brought it up; one of 27 said it did not transfer and one said it transferred a little but did not mind. [2] [5] [6]

Matte Ink is the one Maybelline sells as transfer-proof, and 13% (22 of 169) of its reviewers said it did not transfer or smudge onto cups, masks or teeth, against two who said it did. [4] [7]

How the two feel on lips: moisture, stickiness and dryness

Comfort is where the Serum Lipstick wins. Seven of 27 reviewers called it moisturizing or comfortable, against 5% (8 of 169) for Matte Ink. Six praised a smooth application, against 7%, a smaller lead. [5] [6] [7]

Stickiness and patchiness complaints leaned toward Matte Ink, 19% and 12% of its 169 reviewers, against one and none of the 27 Serum Lipstick reviewers. Drying complaints were about even, 11% against two of 27. [5] [6] [7]

Among the 38 Matte Ink reviewers who gave one or two stars, patchiness and stickiness came up 17 times each and dryness 12. [7]

Launch-wave reviews leaned harder on comfort. Of the 56 from January to March 2026 without a free note, 31 called it moisturizing and 14 lightweight; none of the 27 we kept said lightweight. Those months are out because most reviews posted then were for free product, not because of what they said. [5]

Maybelline Serum Lipstick satin vs matte, and how the shades did

Maybelline makes eight matte shades and eight satin ones, and says the mattes are meant to hydrate where traditional mattes can dry lips. Reviews cannot split the two yet; only three of the 27 we kept named a matte shade and six a satin one. [2] [5] [6]

Praise for the Maybelline Serum Lipstick shades came from 44% (12 of 27) of reviewers, its most common praise, against 34% for Matte Ink. Shade complaints, such as a wrong undertone or too few shades for them, came from 5 of 27, against 9%. [5] [6] [7]

With 27 reviews, each one moves a share by about 4 points, so the shade gap is too close to call. [5] [6]

Maybelline Serum Lipstick vs SuperStay Matte Ink: which to pick

Is Maybelline Serum Lipstick good? For comfort it beat Matte Ink in the reviews we kept, seven of 27 against 5%, though fewer praised its wear. One- and two-star shares were close, 5 of 27 against 22% for Matte Ink. [5] [6] [7]

Pick the Serum Lipstick if comfort matters more than all-day wear and you will touch up after meals. Pick Super Stay Matte Ink if you need color that Maybelline says holds through eating and drinking, and can live with a tackier feel. [5] [6] [7] [2] [4]

Matte Ink's low-star share has moved around by year. One- and two-star reviews ran 26% in 2024, 14% in 2025 and 32% (13 of 41) in 2026, a small base. Two 2026 reviewers said it was not the same as tubes they bought before, and Maybelline says it moved Matte Ink to lighter packaging with the same formula. [7] [4]

How we read the Ulta and Target pages for this check

We read both Ulta pages and Target's Serum Lipstick page on November 17, 2026, collecting the date, stars and labels of every review we could load. For Matte Ink we read reviews written at Ulta from January 2024 on. [5] [6] [7]

Of the 394 reviews we read, 60 said in their own words the lipstick was free or a sample, and 16 more were repeats, about shipping or the store, not used yet or not in English. The 122 that passed those checks but came from the free-product months were set aside too, which left 196. [5] [6] [7]

Our rule sets aside any month with 20 or more reviews on a page when more than half were free products. On the Serum Lipstick page that caught January to March 2026, when 336 of the 394 reviews posted were free, and on the Matte Ink page June and July 2025 (317 of 384). The 56 and 66 reviews from those months without a free note are not in the comparison. [5] [7]

The Serum Lipstick numbers rest on 16 Ulta reviews from April 2026 on and 11 written at Target since November 2025, so each review moves a share by about 4 points. [5] [6]

Our Amazon links use the product numbers we found on November 17, 2026. Amazon's page for Serum Lipstick in Upstate showed Amazon.com as the seller; the Matte Ink page did not show us a seller, so its card says the seller was not confirmed. Claims, shades and sizes come from the Ulta and Maybelline pages; no Amazon reviews, ratings or prices are used.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission when you buy through these paid links.

The two picks on Amazon

Each Amazon link opens the product as Amazon lists it, and its shade may not match the one you want.

For comfort and moisture: Maybelline Serum Lipstick on Amazon (paid link)

For long wear: Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink on Amazon (paid link)

Sellers at our check (November 17, 2026): Amazon.com. Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick: the listing was found but the seller was not readable on November 17, 2026, so check the seller line on Amazon. Offers change, so confirm the name, shade and seller on Amazon before you order.

Keep reading

  • Best matte lipstick? 2,177 reviews of Maybelline, NYX and Charlotte Tilbury
  • Best lip liner? 849 reviews of e.l.f., NYX and Maybelline
  • Is Sky Tubes mascara waterproof? 43 Ulta reviews vs 556 for Sky High

Frequently asked questions

Maybelline Serum Lipstick review: are the Ulta reviews for free product?

Most are. When we read Ulta's page, 334 of the 433 reviews carried Ulta's note that the reviewer got the lipstick in exchange for an honest review, and 24 more said it was free. None of the 334 gave one or two stars. Of the 27 reviews we kept from Ulta and Target, five did.

Is Maybelline Serum Lipstick transfer proof?

No. Maybelline's FAQ says it is not transfer-proof, though it is made to resist feathering, and it suggests touching up after eating. Of the 27 reviews we kept, one said it did not transfer and one said it transferred a little, too few to judge. Super Stay Matte Ink is the one Maybelline sells as transfer-proof.

Does Maybelline Serum Lipstick last as long as Super Stay Matte Ink?

Fewer reviewers praised its wear. Of the 27 Serum Lipstick reviews we kept, eight praised the wear and three said it wore off fast. For Super Stay Matte Ink, 62% of 169 Ulta reviews praised the wear and 9% said it wore off. Maybelline promises 8 hours of moisture for the Serum Lipstick and up to 16 hours of wear for Matte Ink.

Is Maybelline Serum Lipstick drying?

Few reviewers said so. Two of the 27 we kept said it dried their lips, while seven called it moisturizing or comfortable. For Super Stay Matte Ink, 11% said it was drying, about the same share. Maybelline calls its matte Serum Lipstick shades a good choice for dry lips, since traditional mattes can be drying.

Maybelline Serum Lipstick satin vs matte: which should I get?

Maybelline makes eight of each and says the matte shades still hydrate. Reviews cannot settle it yet; only three of the 27 reviewers we kept named a matte shade and six a satin one. Choose by the look you want, matte for a flat finish and satin for a soft sheen, and check the shade on Maybelline's page first.

THE FINAL CHECK

Is this the right choice for your routine?

THE SHORT ANSWER

Serum Lipstick (27 reviews kept, Ulta from April 2026 and Target): 7 moisturizing, 8 long wear, 12 shade praise; 3 wore off fast, 5 shade problems; 5 one or two stars. Super Stay Matte Ink (169 Ulta reviews, 2024 to 2026): 62% long wear, 13% no transfer; 19% sticky or greasy, 12% patchy, 11% drying; 22% one or two stars.

THINK TWICE IF

You need color through meals (Maybelline suggests touching up the Serum Lipstick after eating, and 8 of 27 praised its wear). You want a transfer-proof lipstick (Maybelline's FAQ says the Serum Lipstick is not).

We separate brand claims from customer experiences. We check shopping links and disclose when a purchase may earn us a commission.

OUR SOURCES & HOW WE REVIEW

What we checked.

See where the information comes from and how we reached our take. Brand claims, customer experiences, and our interpretation are identified separately.

  1. Ulta: Maybelline Serum Lipstick. Retailer page read 2026-11-17: 0.12 oz; 16 satin and matte shades; oil blend and hyaluronic acid; 8 hours of plumping moisture; comfortable, barely there feel; lip-hugging bullet; ingredient list.
  2. Maybelline: Moisturizing Serum Lipstick. Brand page read 2026-11-17: up to 35% more hydration instantly, moisture up to 8 hours, no feathering, vegan, 8 matte and 8 satin shades; FAQ: not transfer-proof but feather-resistant, touch up after eating or after eight hours, slight vanilla scent.
  3. Ulta: Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick. Retailer page read 2026-11-17: 0.17 oz; smooth matte finish that lasts all day; arrow tip for precise application; ingredient list with fragrance.
  4. Maybelline: Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick. Brand page read 2026-11-17: up to 16 hours of wear; transfer-proof, smudge-proof, food-resistant; arrow-tip doe-foot applicator; dermatologist tested; lighter packaging, same formula.
  5. Ulta: customer reviews page for Maybelline Serum Lipstick. 99 reviews read on November 17, 2026 (every review on the page, 433 when read, January 20, 2026 to November 11, 2026; all written on Ulta; the 99 without the free-product note read). Tallied by THE BEAUTY READ.
  6. Target: customer reviews page for Maybelline Serum Lipstick with Hyaluronic Acid. 13 reviews read on November 17, 2026 (the newest 408 reviews, November 15, 2025 to October 21, 2026). Tallied by THE BEAUTY READ.
  7. Ulta: customer reviews page for Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick. 282 reviews read on November 17, 2026 (the Reviewed at Ulta.com view, January 1, 2024 to November 15, 2026). Tallied by THE BEAUTY READ.

About this guide: one person's trial can miss what many buyers run into, so we count what buyers repeat in the customer reviews listed above, which are not every review on each site. The shares describe other people's experiences, not our own hands-on test, and the picks follow those patterns; they are not a ranking. No review text is reproduced, and Amazon reviews, ratings and prices are not used.

Retailer prices, review totals and product information can change. This article is not medical advice.

How we read reviewsReport a correction

Keep reading

Explore all articles →

More review analyses: Dr.Jart+ moisturizers · LANEIGE lip products · Medicube Zero Pore Pad · UNOVE hair treatment · Korean collagen masks · e.l.f. Halo Glow · ceramide creams for dry skin

Redken Acidic Grow vs Acidic Bonding: Fuller or Softer Hair?

Redken Acidic Grow vs Acidic Bonding: Fuller or Softer Hair?

Versace Crystal Emerald vs Bright Crystal: Longer Wear, More Soap Talk

Versace Crystal Emerald vs Bright Crystal: Longer Wear, More Soap Talk

Is Eadem Lip Gloss Worth It? 1,640 Reviews vs ILIA's New Overglaze

Is Eadem Lip Gloss Worth It? 1,640 Reviews vs ILIA's New Overglaze

THE INDEPENDENT BEAUTY EDIT

THE BEAUTY READ

Less guessing. More good questions. Beauty reviews that help you decide what belongs in your routine.

Explore our reviews →
EXPLORE
ArticlesSkincareSuncareMakeupHairBodyBeauty ToolsBeauty IntelligenceFragrance
THE PUBLICATION
AboutContactPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service
© 2026 THE BEAUTY READ. MORE CONTEXT, BETTER CHOICES.INDEPENDENT BEAUTY REVIEWS