Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere: 517 Usable Reviews

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links marked “paid link” earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never decide which product we recommend. Offers and sellers change, so check the name, size and seller on the product page before you buy.

Review-analysis guide: 1,307 customer reviews read on Target and Ulta (November 12, 2026), sorted and counted by us; product details from the Target and Ulta listings checked November 12, 2026.

By The Beauty Read · Checked November 12, 2026 · AI-assisted research and editing · Contains Amazon affiliate links

In Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere, fewer eos reviewers said the scent faded fast, 10% of 353 against 23% of 164 for Athena, and the gap held on reviews written on Target (14% vs 31%). Athena drew no alcohol-smell complaints, while 11% of eos reviewers noticed one.

Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere: what 1,307 reviews show

Vanilla body mists are the easy way to smell like dessert without committing to a perfume, and eos and Athena Club both make one. To settle athena golden vanilla vs eos vanilla cashmere, we read the eos and Athena cards on Target until the Show more button ran out, eos's Ulta page and Being Frenshe's Cashmere Vanilla on Ulta and Target, 1,307 in all, and counted what reviewers said about the scent, how long it lasted and the bottle. [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]

All three are built for hair and body. eos lists denatured alcohol first, with water, fragrance, glycerin and also hyaluronic acid, and notes of whipped vanilla, sweet cream, musk and caramel. Athena Club describes coconut, vanilla ice cream and warm amber with a softer, skin-like finish, and Target shows no ingredient list for it. Being Frenshe pairs vanilla with toasted jasmine rice, amber and musk over an alcohol base with essential oils. [1] [2] [3]

Their records are uneven. After promotion months, free-product reviews, repeats and all-scent reviews that named no scent were set aside, 353 usable reviews remained for eos, 164 for Athena and only 9 for Being Frenshe, so its numbers below are counts, not percentages. [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]

Does Athena Club body mist last? Golden Vanilla's record

Target loaded 204 Golden Vanilla cards before its Show more button ran out, back to January 14, 2026, and 112 of them came from Athena Club's own site. We set aside February 2026 from that source because 17 of its 31 cards said they got the mist free or as part of a promotion. After 9 other exclusions, 164 usable reviews remained. [6]

People liked the smell. 74% said so and 12% praised it as soft rather than loud, about the same share as for eos. Asked plainly, does athena club body mist last? Not for many of them. 23% said it faded fast and 13% said it lasted, and among reviews written on Target the fade share rose to 31%. [6]

That shapes any athena club golden vanilla body mist review we could write. 17% gave one or two stars, 8% called it a repurchase or staple, and only 2% said it smelled different from what they expected. 29 of the 38 who said it faded fast still liked the scent. [6]

What an eos vanilla cashmere body mist review shows about the alcohol note

The eos page on Target loaded 398 cards back to October 14, 2025 before its Show more button ran out, and 182 of them came from eos's own site. Those same eos-site reviews also fill most of Ulta's all-scent eos page, so we counted each once and kept only Ulta reviews that named Vanilla Cashmere. [4] [5]

Our eos vanilla cashmere body mist review starts with the scent. 76% liked it, 25% said it lasted and 10% said it faded fast. Among reviews written on Target the lasted share was 20%, close to Athena's 16%, while the fade share stayed lower at 14%. So is eos body mist long lasting? Fewer reviewers said it faded than for Athena, though most simply didn't say. [4] [5]

Then there is the spray itself. 11% noticed an alcohol smell when they sprayed it, rising to 18% among reviews written on Target, and 24 of those 40 gave one or two stars. The ingredient list does start with denatured alcohol. Another 6% reported sprayer or bottle problems such as clogs, leaks or damage, 21 of them in reviews written on Target. [4] [5] [1]

Being Frenshe Cashmere Vanilla body mist and its promotion-heavy pages

The being frenshe cashmere vanilla body mist has plenty of reviews but few we could use. On Ulta, 88 of its 110 reviews said they got the mist free or in exchange for a review, 83 of them among the 101 posted in June and July 2026, so we set both months aside. [8]

Target's page pools every Being Frenshe mist scent. Of its 408 newest cards, all 249 posted from Being Frenshe's own site said they got it free or as part of a promotion, which set them aside whatever their scent, and of the rest 100 named no scent and 42 named another. [7]

That leaves 9 usable reviews. All 9 liked the scent, 5 sprayed it on pillows, linens, clothes or a room and 3 called it a repurchase or staple. That is too few to compare its staying power with eos or Athena. [7] [8]

How long the scent lasted on eos and Athena

Lining up eos vanilla cashmere vs athena club golden vanilla on reviews written on Target alone, 20% of eos reviewers said it lasted and 14% said it faded, against 16% and 31% for Athena. The fade gap holds when brand-site reviews are added back, while most of the wider gap in 'it lasted' (25% vs 13%) comes from those brand-site reviews. [4] [5] [6]

Layering came up often. 54 eos reviewers said they wore it over a lotion, oil or perfume, and 20 of them said it lasted, against 67 of the 299 who didn't mention layering. Most of those layerers (35) were eos-site reviews, which reported lasting more often anyway. For Athena, 5 of the 20 who layered said it lasted. [4] [5] [6]

Hair use came up rarely, 3 times for eos and 4 for Athena, so the reviews can't say whether spraying hair or clothes keeps the scent longer. Shoppers after an eos vanilla cashmere body mist dupe won't find much here either, since only 5 eos reviewers compared it with a named pricier fragrance. [4] [5] [6]

Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere: which one to pick

Our read on athena golden vanilla vs eos vanilla cashmere: pick eos if fading fast is your main worry and an alcohol smell when you spray doesn't bother you. Pick Athena if an alcohol smell when you spray is your main worry, since none of its 164 usable reviewers mentioned one (Target lists no ingredients for it), and you don't mind topping it up. [4] [5] [6]

Weigh the source as well. Reviews shown from the brands' own sites were far kinder, with one or two stars 2% of the time for eos and 7% for Athena, while reviews written on Target did so 28% and 26% of the time. [4] [6]

Buying differs too. We link eos and Being Frenshe to Amazon listings found in search, with the seller unconfirmed. Athena's Amazon link is paused because we found only reseller-style listings, so we point to the Target page instead. [2]

How we read the Target and Ulta pages for this check

Three blocks were set aside whole. Athena Club's own site sent 31 cards to Target in February 2026, and 17 of them said they got the mist free or as part of a promotion. All 249 Being Frenshe-site cards on Target said they got it free or as part of a promotion, 236 of them from June to September 2026, and Ulta's Being Frenshe page took 101 of its 110 reviews in June and July 2026, 83 of which said the mist was free or received in exchange for a review. In months with 20 or more cards from one source, when more than half said that, we dropped the whole month, organic reviews included. [6] [7] [8]

Of the 1,307 cards we read, 368 sat in those months. Another 50 said the product was free or came from a promotion, 113 on the two pages that pool every scent named no scent at all, 48 were about a different scent or product, 160 repeated a card we already had (mostly eos-site reviews that appear on both Target and Ulta), and 42 were about shipping only, not yet used, empty or in another language. That left 526. [4] [5] [6] [7] [8]

Many cards were not written on the store's own page. On Target, 182 of the 398 eos cards came from eos's own site and 112 of the 204 Athena cards from Athena Club's. We kept them, apart from 23 eos-site cards that said they were free or from a promotion and the other exclusions above, and tracked their source, since they rated higher. Reviews shown from the brand sites gave one or two stars 2% of the time for eos and 7% for Athena, against 28% and 26% for reviews written on Target. [4] [6]

Target kept loading eos and Athena cards until its Show more button ran out, back to October 14, 2025 and January 14, 2026. Its Being Frenshe page stopped after the 408 newest cards, out of 2,576 written reviews spread across every scent, so we kept only those naming Cashmere Vanilla. Ulta's eos page also pools every scent, and 159 of its 187 cards matched eos-site reviews already read on Target. [4] [6] [7] [5]

Our Amazon links open listings we found through search results on November 12, 2026; Amazon's own pages would not load for us, so we could not read who sells them, and each card says so. For Athena Club Golden Vanilla we found only reseller-style listings, so its link is paused and we point to the Target page instead, which is not an affiliate link. Every product detail here comes from the Target and Ulta pages, not from Amazon.

Keep reading

• Best vanilla body wash: Dove, eos and Athena Club
• eos body lotion in Vanilla Cashmere, Fresh & Cozy and Strawberry
• Best vanilla perfume: 750 Sephora reviews of three cozy picks

Frequently asked questions

Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere: which lasts longer?

Reviewers leaned toward eos, mainly on fading. 10% of 353 usable eos reviewers said it faded fast, against 23% of 164 for Athena Club. Saying it lasted was close among reviews written on Target, 20% vs 16%, and most reviewers of both didn't mention staying power at all.

Is eos body mist long lasting?

Some eos Vanilla Cashmere reviewers said so. 25% said the scent lasted, 20% among reviews written on Target, and 10% said it faded fast, fewer than for Athena. The label calls it a long-lasting scent, but most reviewers didn't say how long it stayed on.

Why does eos Vanilla Cashmere smell like alcohol at first?

Its ingredient list starts with denatured alcohol, and some reviewers smelled it when they sprayed. 11% of usable eos reviewers noticed it, 18% among reviews written on Target, and 24 of those 40 gave one or two stars. No Athena reviewer mentioned an alcohol smell, though Target shows no ingredient list for Athena's mist.

Why isn't Athena Club Golden Vanilla linked to Amazon?

When we searched on November 12, 2026, search results showed only reseller-style listings for it, with odd titles or no scent named, and Amazon's pages would not load for us to check the seller. We paused that link and point to the Target page instead, which is not an affiliate link.

Why are there so few Being Frenshe Cashmere Vanilla reviews here?

Most of its reviews could not be counted. On Ulta, 88 of the 110 Cashmere Vanilla reviews said the mist was free or received for a review. Target's page mixes every Being Frenshe scent, all 249 brand-site cards there said they got it free or as part of a promotion, and 100 other cards named no scent. 9 usable reviews remained.