Best Eye Cream? 878 Reviews of RoC, CeraVe and TULA

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links marked “paid link” earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never decide which product we recommend. Offers and sellers change, so check the option and seller on the product page before you buy.

Review-analysis guide: 878 customer reviews read on Ulta (October 26, 2026), sorted and counted by us; product details from Amazon listings checked October 26, 2026.

By The Beauty Read · Checked October 26, 2026 · AI-assisted research and editing · Contains Amazon affiliate links

The best eye cream in these reviews depends on what you want. RoC (paid link) drew the most fine-line praise (24% of 143 usable Ulta reviews) and the fewest one- and two-star reviews (23%). CeraVe (paid link) drew the most hydration praise (28%) but also the most saw-no-difference reports (29%). TULA (paid link) drew the most cooling (40%) and glow (27%) praise and the most irritation reports (30%).

Best eye cream: what 878 reviews say

Looking for the best eye cream? We read 878 Ulta reviews of three popular under eye cream picks to see how often reviewers say it made fine lines look smoother, hydrated or brightened, and how often it stung, did nothing or let them down: RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream, CeraVe Eye Repair Cream and TULA Glow + Get It Eye Balm. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL] [A1] [A2] [A3]

RoC drew the most fine-line praise (24% of 143 usable reviews), against 7% for CeraVe (287) and 3% for TULA (291), and the fewest one- and two-star reviews (23%, against 36% and 44%). CeraVe drew the most hydration praise (28%) and the most saw-no-difference reports (29%). TULA drew the most cooling (40%) and glow (27%) praise and the most irritation reports (30%). [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

How we read 878 Ulta reviews to find the best eye cream

We read every distinct review Ulta's pages served for these three, with no fixed target. Ulta's review pages stop after about 300, so we read 293 of 5,147 shown for RoC (about 6%), 290 of 566 for CeraVe and 295 of 536 for TULA. These are the newest Ulta served, yet for CeraVe and TULA most still date from 2019 to 2022, and they may not represent older reviews. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

Of the 878 we read, 157 were set aside. 142 were RoC reviews from two bursts that were far more positive than the rest: January to April 2022, which held 11 of its 14 free-sample reviews, and June 2025, when none of 30 reviews gave one or two stars. The other 15 said the product was free or a sample (3), were about another product (5), repeated on the same page (5), were about shipping (1) or came from someone who had not used it (1). That leaves 721 usable reviews: 143 for RoC, 287 for CeraVe and 291 for TULA. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

Some cautions. All reviews come from one retailer, and they cover different years: most CeraVe reviews date from 2019 to 2021 and most TULA reviews from 2021 and 2022, while RoC's usable reviews run from May 2022 to March 2026. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

RoC retinol eye cream drew the most fine-line praise

Searching for the RoC eye cream? RoC's listing describes Retinol Correxion as RoC Retinol with a mineral complex, hypoallergenic and designed to be gentle enough for daily use, aimed at the look of puffiness, dark circles and wrinkles. Its label says to keep it out of the eyes and to stop use and ask a doctor if rash or irritation develops and lasts. We link the 0.5 oz cream shipped and sold by Amazon.com; Ulta sells the same cream as Retinol Line Smoothing Eye Cream. [A1]

Across 143 usable Ulta reviews of RoC Retinol Correxion, 34 (24%) said fine lines looked smoother, 21 (15%) would buy it again, 18 (13%) called it a good value, 16 (11%) liked the texture and 13 (9%) said dark circles looked lighter. Complaints: 24 (17%) saw no difference, 16 (11%) described irritation and 9 (6%) had a packaging problem. 33 (23%) gave one or two stars, the fewest of the three. [R-ULT-ROC]

See RoC Retinol Correxion Under Eye Cream, 0.5 oz on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens the 0.5 oz RoC Retinol Correxion eye cream shipped and sold by Amazon.com.

CeraVe eye cream: most hydration praise, most saw no change

CeraVe's listing describes Eye Repair Cream as a non-greasy cream with hyaluronic acid, niacinamide and three ceramides that helps reduce the look of puffiness, used as a pea-sized amount morning and night; it says it is ophthalmologist tested. We link the 0.5 oz tube shipped and sold by Amazon.com. [A2]

In 287 usable Ulta reviews of the CeraVe eye cream, 80 (28%) said it hydrated, 46 (16%) would buy it again, 37 (13%) called it a good value, 33 (11%) said dark circles looked lighter and 27 (9%) said it felt gentle. On the other side, 84 (29%) saw no difference, 52 (18%) described irritation and 20 (7%) said it was not moisturizing enough, and 102 (36%) gave one or two stars. [R-ULT-CER]

See CeraVe Eye Repair Cream, 0.5 oz on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens the 0.5 oz CeraVe Eye Repair Cream shipped and sold by Amazon.com.

TULA Glow + Get It drew the most cooling praise and irritation reports

TULA's Amazon listing is shared across its eye balm sticks; we link it with the Glow + Get It option selected, sold by TULA Skin Care. Its bullets, shared across TULA's eye balms rather than written for Glow + Get It alone, describe a hyaluronic acid and aloe water balm that hydrates and reduces the look of fine lines and puffiness. [A3]

In 291 usable Ulta reviews of TULA Glow + Get It, 116 (40%) liked the cooling feel, 80 (27%) said it gave a brighter or glowy look, 28 (10%) would buy it again and 20 (7%) said it worked well under makeup. On the other side, 86 (30%) described burning, stinging, itching, redness, a rash or watery eyes, 62 (21%) saw no difference and 27 (9%) said it was not moisturizing enough, and 129 (44%) gave one or two stars. [R-ULT-TUL]

See TULA Glow + Get It Eye Balm Stick on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens TULA's eye balm listing with the Glow + Get It option selected, sold by TULA Skin Care; check the option before you order.

Under eye cream for sensitive eyes and dark circles, and how each one feels

Of reviewers who said they have sensitive skin or eyes, 4 of 9 for RoC, 10 of 20 for CeraVe and 11 of 15 for TULA said it felt gentle; these groups are small. Overall irritation reports ran from 11% for RoC to 30% for TULA. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

Shopping for an eye cream for dark circles? CeraVe drew the most dark-circle praise (11%, against 9% for RoC and 6% for TULA), but of 23 CeraVe reviewers who bought it for dark circles, 4 said they looked lighter and 12 saw no difference. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

On feel, 11% of RoC and CeraVe and 10% of TULA reviewers liked the texture, and few found any of them greasy (1% to 4%). Under makeup, 11 of 16 TULA and 10 of 15 CeraVe reviewers who wore it there said it worked well. [R-ULT-ROC] [R-ULT-CER] [R-ULT-TUL]

Keep reading

• Peptide serum: The Ordinary, Biossance and COSRX
• Azelaic acid: The Ordinary, Paula's Choice and Anua
• Best face moisturizer: First Aid Beauty, Tatcha and Laneige

Frequently asked questions

What is the best eye cream for fine lines in these reviews?

The best eye cream for fine lines here was RoC Retinol Correxion: 24% of 143 usable Ulta reviews said lines looked smoother, against 7% for CeraVe and 3% for TULA, and 23% gave one or two stars, the fewest of the three. 17% saw no difference. Its label says to keep it out of the eyes.

Does CeraVe eye cream work for dark circles?

For some reviewers. 11% of 287 usable Ulta reviews said dark circles looked lighter, the most of the three, but of 23 reviewers who bought it for dark circles, only 4 said so and 12 saw no difference. Overall, 29% saw no difference and 28% praised the hydration.

Did reviewers with sensitive eyes find RoC's retinol eye cream gentle?

Mixed, in a small group: of 9 RoC reviewers who said they have sensitive skin or eyes, 4 found it gentle and 3 described irritation. Overall, 11% described irritation, the least of the three. We cannot say whether it suits your eyes; its label says to keep it out of the eyes and to stop use and ask a doctor if rash or irritation develops and lasts.

Do reviewers say TULA Glow + Get It stings?

Many did: 30% of 291 usable Ulta reviews described burning, stinging, itching, redness, a rash or watery eyes, the most of the three, and 44% gave one or two stars. At the same time, 40% liked the cooling feel and 27% the glowy look.

Which under eye cream do reviewers buy again?

CeraVe (16% of 287 usable Ulta reviews) and RoC (15% of 143) drew similar repurchase mentions, ahead of TULA (10%). Both also drew similar value mentions (13%), while RoC drew the fewest one- and two-star reviews (23%).