THEBEAUTY READ
ArticlesSkincareSuncareMakeupHairBodyBeauty ToolsBeauty IntelligenceBeauty Now
Explore reviews ↗
Menu ☰
ArticlesSkincareSuncareMakeupHairBodyBeauty ToolsBeauty IntelligenceBeauty Now
Home
›
Articles
›
Best Lip Balm? 866 Reviews of Aquaphor, La Roche-Posay and e.l.f.
October 26, 2026

Best Lip Balm? 866 Reviews of Aquaphor, La Roche-Posay and e.l.f.

IN THIS REVIEWThe quick takeCompare the optionsSources & limitsHow we review

THE BEAUTY READ / FIND YOUR FIT

The decision, simplified.

Which lip balm actually works? What 866 Ulta reviews of Aquaphor, La Roche-Posay and e.l.f. say about moisture, chapped lips, wear and flavor.

By THE BEAUTY READ · 6 min read
Review-analysis guide: 866 reviews read on Ulta

Published Oct 26, 2026 · Listings checked October 26, 2026

AI-generated still life: a plain unlabeled lip balm stick, squeeze tube, tin and glass jar on blush plaster with lavender, honey and a linen towel.
AI-generated editorial image; the real Aquaphor, La Roche-Posay and e.l.f. balms look different.

THE BEAUTY READ · REVIEW ANALYSIS

We read 866 customer reviews before writing this.

Ulta · October 26, 2026

Where we read, how many and when
RetailerReviews readWhich onesRead on
Ulta · Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick290every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 290 of 2,834 shown, Jan 22, 2025 to Mar 28, 2026October 26, 2026
Ulta · La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5291every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 291 of 622 shown, Aug 29, 2023 to May 6, 2026October 26, 2026
Ulta · e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm285every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 285 of 807 shown, Jul 10, 2024 to Jul 18, 2026October 26, 2026

Where we read, how many and when

RetailerUlta · Aquaphor Lip Repair StickUlta · La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5
Reviews read290291
Which onesevery distinct review Ulta's pages served, 290 of 2,834 shown, Jan 22, 2025 to Mar 28, 2026every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 291 of 622 shown, Aug 29, 2023 to May 6, 2026
Read onOctober 26, 2026October 26, 2026
RetailerUlta · e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm
Reviews read285
Which onesevery distinct review Ulta's pages served, 285 of 807 shown, Jul 10, 2024 to Jul 18, 2026
Read onOctober 26, 2026

How we sorted them: result: moisturized or softer lips, healed chapped or cracked lips, lasted long or overnight; or did not hydrate, wore off fast; feel and use: texture, sticky or greasy, flavor or scent liked or disliked, sheer tint, packaging problems, small for the price, irritation they described; who: very dry or chapped lips, sensitive lips, overnight or winter use as stated; one- and two-star share reported for context.

Left out of the count: reviews that say the product was free, a sample or from a review program, and every review from a month where most reviews said so or where a burst of sampled reviews skewed one product (July 2025 Aquaphor, September 2023 La Roche-Posay); reviews about another product, from someone who had not used it, repeated, about shipping only, and reviews with no meaningful text (54 said they got it free or as a sample, 113 from a September 2023 La Roche-Posay wave that held all 27 of its free-sample reviews and was far more positive than the rest, 29 from a July 2025 Aquaphor wave in which 15 of 29 said they got it free, 17 repeated on the same page, 1 about shipping only, 1 no meaningful text, 1 about another product, 1 had not used it).

Usable reviews per balm: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick (204 usable); La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 (172 usable); e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm (273 usable)

WHO SHOULD SKIP IT

  • You want the fewest letdowns. 21% of La Roche-Posay reviewers said it did not hydrate or wore off fast and 22% gave one or two stars, against 7% and 5% for Aquaphor.
  • You dislike flavored or tacky balms. 8% of e.l.f. reviewers disliked the flavor or scent and 9% found it sticky; Aquaphor's listing says fragrance free.
  • You go through balm quickly. 9% of e.l.f. and 8% of La Roche-Posay reviewers said it was small for the price or ran out fast, against 0% for Aquaphor.

MOST OFTEN PRAISED

  • Moisturizing, softer lips Aquaphor 54%; La Roche-Posay 40%; e.l.f. 32%: soft, hydrated lips
  • Healed chapped or cracked lips La Roche-Posay 22%; Aquaphor 14%; e.l.f. 3%: fixed peeling or cracks
  • Would buy again e.l.f. 24%; La Roche-Posay 17%; Aquaphor 10%: repurchase or holy grail
  • Flavor or scent liked e.l.f. 41%; Aquaphor 11%; La Roche-Posay 2%: tasty or pleasant

MOST COMMON COMPLAINTS

  • Did not hydrate or wore off fast La Roche-Posay 21%; e.l.f. 12%; Aquaphor 7%: lips still dry, constant reapplying
  • Sticky, greasy or waxy e.l.f. 9%; La Roche-Posay 2%; Aquaphor 1%: heavy or tacky feel
  • Small for the price or ran out fast e.l.f. 9%; La Roche-Posay 8%; Aquaphor 0%: tube emptied fast
  • Packaging problem La Roche-Posay 9%; e.l.f. 2%; Aquaphor 1%: tube or cap issues

Where reviews split: Very dry lips: of reviewers who said they bought it for very dry, chapped or cracked lips, 23 of 43 for La Roche-Posay and 8 of 15 for Aquaphor said it healed them (e.l.f. had 9 such reviewers).

Where reviews split: Sensitive lips: 7 of 11 La Roche-Posay reviewers who said they have sensitive lips or skin said it felt gentle.

How reviewers used it: 43 La Roche-Posay, 15 Aquaphor and 9 e.l.f. reviewers said they had very dry or chapped lips; 13, 3 and 4 used it overnight; 23, 22 and 5 in cold or dry weather.

Feel, per reviewers: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick (25% liked the texture); La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 (13% liked the texture); e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm (19% liked the texture; 13% liked the tint or shine)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Good fit for Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 oz if you want a plain, fragrance-free balm that drew the most moisture praise and fewest complaints in these reviews.

Check the current price on Amazon ↗ (paid link)

Good fit for La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 if your lips are cracked or peeling and you want the balm reviewers most often said healed them.

Check the current price on Amazon ↗ (paid link)

Good fit for e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry if you want a sheer-tint balm whose flavor reviewers liked and often rebuy.

Check the current price on Amazon ↗ (paid link)

THE BEAUTY READ · BUYING GUIDE

Most moisture praise, fewest complaints: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick (54% said moisturizing; 7% said it did not hydrate or wore off). Most healed-lips praise and most low ratings: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 (22% healed; 21% did not hydrate or wore off; 22% one or two stars). Most flavor, value and repurchase talk: e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm (41% liked the flavor, 24% would buy again; 9% sticky).

Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 and e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm | 866 customer reviews read on Ulta, October 26, 2026 · Listings checked October 26, 2026

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links marked “paid link” go to Amazon and may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Offers and sellers can change.

Choose your starting point

THE BEAUTY READ01

Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 oz

MOST MOISTURE PRAISE, FEWEST COMPLAINTS

Most moisture praise, fewest complaints

54%said it moisturized · 111 of 204 usable reviews [R-ULT-AQU]

You want a plain, fragrance-free balm that drew the most moisture praise and fewest complaints in these reviews.

The trade-off7% did not hydrate or wore off; reviews from 2025 and 2026 only.

See it on Amazon · paid link ↗Compare ↓

Sold by Amazon.com at our check
October 26, 2026

THE BEAUTY READ02

La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5

MOST HEALING PRAISE, MOST LOW RATINGS

Most healing praise, most low ratings

22%said it healed chapped or cracked lips · 38 of 172 usable reviews [R-ULT-LRP]

Your lips are cracked or peeling and you want the balm reviewers most often said healed them.

The trade-off21% did not hydrate or wore off; 9% packaging.

See it on Amazon · paid link ↗Compare ↓

Sold by Amazon.com at our check
October 26, 2026

THE BEAUTY READ03

e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry

MOST FLAVOR, VALUE AND REPURCHASE TALK

Most flavor, value and repurchase talk

24%would buy it again · 65 of 273 usable reviews [R-ULT-ELF]

You want a sheer-tint balm whose flavor reviewers liked and often rebuy.

The trade-off9% sticky; 9% small or ran out; 8% disliked flavor.

See it on Amazon · paid link ↗Compare ↓

Sold by Amazon.com at our check
October 26, 2026

Compare all 3 side by side ↓

Shop the three picks

The exact Amazon options we checked on October 26, 2026. Confirm the option and seller on the page before you order.

Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick on Amazon (paid link)

La Roche-Posay Cicaplast on Amazon (paid link)

e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm on Amazon (paid link)

THE BEAUTY READ · EDITOR'S GUIDE

Find the fit for your routine.

A quick editorial read before the deeper review: start with your main concern, then check the evidence, routine fit and trade-offs below.

01

Quick verdict

Most moisture praise, fewest complaints: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick (54% said moisturizing; 7% said it did not hydrate or wore off). Most healed-lips praise and most low ratings: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 (22% healed; 21% did not hydrate or wore off; 22% one or two stars). Most flavor, value and repurchase talk: e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm (41% liked the flavor, 24% would buy again; 9% sticky).

02

Best for

Anyone choosing an everyday balm for dry or chapped lips who wants to know which one reviewers say moisturizes, and which one draws more complaints.

03

Trade-off

La Roche-Posay drew the most did-not-hydrate or wore-off complaints (21%), packaging complaints (9%) and one- and two-star reviews (22%). e.l.f. drew the most sticky (9%) and disliked-flavor (8%) complaints. Aquaphor's 204 usable reviews all date from 2025 and 2026.

04

Think twice

You want the fewest letdowns: 21% of La Roche-Posay reviewers said it did not hydrate or wore off and 22% gave one or two stars. You dislike flavored or tacky balms: 8% of e.l.f. reviewers disliked the flavor or scent and 9% found it sticky. You go through balm fast: 9% of e.l.f. and 8% of La Roche-Posay reviewers said it was small for the price or ran out fast.

THE BEAUTY READ TAKE

Pick by your lips. For plain, fragrance-free moisture with the fewest complaints, Aquaphor. For cracked lips, La Roche-Posay drew the most healing talk, though more reviewers said it did not hydrate or wore off. For a sheer-tint balm with a flavor people rebuy, e.l.f.

THE COMPARISON / RESEARCH-LED

Side by side, without the noise.

Compare each option’s role and limitations before deciding what belongs in your routine.

The exact options we link: format, size and seller

Three lip balms in three formats. Details follow the Amazon listings; the review counts are ours.

Format, option, seller and the exact Amazon option · Links checked October 26, 2026
Product / Amazon linkPick it forFormat · option · sellerChoose it ifWatch out forOption we link
Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 oz
View on Amazon · paid link ↗
Most moisture praise, fewest complaintsFragrance-free stick
2 x 0.17 oz · sold by Amazon.com
You want a plain, fragrance-free balm that drew the most moisture praise and fewest complaints in these reviews.7% did not hydrate or wore off; reviews from 2025 and 2026 only.This link opens the two-stick value pack (0.17 oz each) shipped and sold by Amazon.com.
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5
View on Amazon · paid link ↗
Most healing praise, most low ratingsTube balm for very dry lips
Single tube · sold by Amazon.com
Your lips are cracked or peeling and you want the balm reviewers most often said healed them.21% did not hydrate or wore off; 9% packaging.This link opens the Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 tube shipped and sold by Amazon.com.
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry
View on Amazon · paid link ↗
Most flavor, value and repurchase talkSheer-tint squeeze tube
Strawberry, 0.21 oz · sold by Amazon.com
You want a sheer-tint balm whose flavor reviewers liked and often rebuy.9% sticky; 9% small or ran out; 8% disliked flavor.This link opens the Strawberry option (0.21 oz) shipped and sold by Amazon.com.
Seller at our check: Amazon.com

Format, option, seller and the exact Amazon option · Links checked October 26, 2026

Product / Amazon linkAquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 ozLa Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5
Pick it forMost moisture praise, fewest complaintsMost healing praise, most low ratings
Format · option · sellerFragrance-free stick
2 x 0.17 oz · sold by Amazon.com
Tube balm for very dry lips
Single tube · sold by Amazon.com
Choose it ifYou want a plain, fragrance-free balm that drew the most moisture praise and fewest complaints in these reviews.Your lips are cracked or peeling and you want the balm reviewers most often said healed them.
Watch out for7% did not hydrate or wore off; reviews from 2025 and 2026 only.21% did not hydrate or wore off; 9% packaging.
Option we linkThis link opens the two-stick value pack (0.17 oz each) shipped and sold by Amazon.com.
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
This link opens the Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 tube shipped and sold by Amazon.com.
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
View on Amazon ↗
(paid link)
View on Amazon ↗
(paid link)
Product / Amazon linke.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry
Pick it forMost flavor, value and repurchase talk
Format · option · sellerSheer-tint squeeze tube
Strawberry, 0.21 oz · sold by Amazon.com
Choose it ifYou want a sheer-tint balm whose flavor reviewers liked and often rebuy.
Watch out for9% sticky; 9% small or ran out; 8% disliked flavor.
Option we linkThis link opens the Strawberry option (0.21 oz) shipped and sold by Amazon.com.
Seller at our check: Amazon.com
View on Amazon ↗
(paid link)
AI-generated still life: a plain unlabeled lip balm stick, squeeze tube, tin and glass jar on blush plaster with lavender, honey and a linen towel.
THE LINEUP · AT A GLANCE

What changes from one option to the next?

Use this as the fast filter. The full review below explains the evidence, texture, routine fit and trade-offs behind the recommendation.

BEST FOR

Anyone choosing an everyday balm for dry or chapped lips who wants to know which one reviewers say moisturizes, and which one draws more complaints.

TEXTURE

Three lip balms: a fragrance-free stick, a tube balm for very dry lips and a sheer-tint squeeze tube

FEELS LIKE

TBR
ROUTINE FIT · BEFORE YOU BUY

Make sure it fits the routine you already have.

The most useful product is not the one with the loudest ingredient story. It is the one you can use consistently without creating unnecessary overlap.

REVIEW SIGNAL

Review-based guide: we read 866 customer reviews on Ulta (October 26, 2026) and tallied the patterns ourselves; product facts come from Amazon listings.

BIGGEST STRENGTH

Aquaphor led on moisture (54%) and texture (25%) with the fewest one- and two-star reviews (5%). La Roche-Posay led on healed chapped lips (22%). e.l.f. led on flavor (41%), value (26%), repurchase (24%) and tint (13%).

WATCH FOR

La Roche-Posay drew the most did-not-hydrate or wore-off complaints (21%), packaging complaints (9%) and one- and two-star reviews (22%). e.l.f. drew the most sticky (9%) and disliked-flavor (8%) complaints. Aquaphor's 204 usable reviews all date from 2025 and 2026.

TBR ROUTINE NOTE

Check the exact version, label and directions. Your sensitivities, daily setting and existing routine can change the practical fit.

EDITORIAL STANDARD

Our verdict separates recurring user experience from ingredient theory and marketing claims.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links marked “paid link” earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never decide which product we recommend. Offers and sellers change, so check the option and seller on the product page before you buy.

Review-analysis guide: 866 customer reviews read on Ulta (October 26, 2026), sorted and counted by us; product details from Amazon listings checked October 26, 2026.

By The Beauty Read · Checked October 26, 2026 · AI-assisted research and editing · Contains Amazon affiliate links

The best lip balm here depends on your lips. Aquaphor (paid link) drew the most moisture praise (54% of 204 usable Ulta reviews, against 40% for La Roche-Posay (paid link) and 32% for e.l.f. (paid link)) and the fewest complaints. La Roche-Posay drew the most healed-lips praise (22%) and the most did-not-hydrate or wore-off complaints (21%). e.l.f. drew the most flavor (41%), value (26%) and repurchase (24%) mentions.

Best lip balm for dry lips: what 866 reviews say

Looking for the best lip balm for dry lips? We read 866 Ulta reviews of three popular balms to see how often reviewers say it moisturized, healed chapped lips and lasted, and how often it did not hydrate, felt sticky or ran out: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 and e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm. [R-ULT-AQU] [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-ELF] [A1] [A2] [A3]

Aquaphor drew the most moisture praise (54% of 204 usable reviews), against 40% for La Roche-Posay (172) and 32% for e.l.f. (273). La Roche-Posay drew the most healed-lips praise (22%) but also the most did-not-hydrate or wore-off complaints (21%). e.l.f. drew the most flavor (41%), value (26%) and repurchase (24%) mentions. [R-ULT-AQU] [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-ELF]

How we read 866 Ulta reviews to find the best lip balm

We read every distinct review Ulta's pages served for these three balms, with no fixed target. Ulta's review pages stop after about 300, so we read 290 of 2,834 shown for Aquaphor (about 10%), 291 of 622 for La Roche-Posay and 285 of 807 for e.l.f. The ones we read are the newest, so they may not represent older reviews. [R-ULT-AQU] [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-ELF]

Of the 866 we read, 217 were set aside: 113 La Roche-Posay reviews from September 2023, the month that held all 27 of its free-sample reviews and was far more positive than the rest; 54 Aquaphor reviews that said the balm was free or a sample; 29 from a July 2025 Aquaphor wave in which 15 of the 29 said they got it free; 17 repeated on the same page; and 4 about shipping, another product, not used or with no meaningful text. That leaves 649 usable reviews: 204 for Aquaphor, 172 for La Roche-Posay and 273 for e.l.f. [R-ULT-AQU] [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-ELF]

Some cautions. All reviews come from one retailer, and the three sets cover different years: Aquaphor's usable reviews all date from 2025 and 2026, La Roche-Posay's mostly from 2024, and e.l.f.'s from mid-2024 on. 69 of the 290 Aquaphor reviews we read said the balm was free or a sample. [R-ULT-AQU] [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-ELF]

Bar chart by THE BEAUTY READ: what usable customer reviews of three lip balms reported (Aquaphor 204, La Roche-Posay 172, e.l.f. 273 usable reviews). Praised: Moisturizing: Aquaphor 54%, La Roche-Posay 40%, e.l.f. 32%; Said it healed chapped lips: Aquaphor 14%, La Roche-Posay 22%, e.l.f. 3%; Long-lasting: Aquaphor 12%, La Roche-Posay 13%, e.l.f. 7%; Liked flavor or scent: Aquaphor 11%, La Roche-Posay 2%, e.l.f. 41%; Would buy again: Aquaphor 10%, La Roche-Posay 17%, e.l.f. 24%. Complaints: Didn't hydrate or wore off: Aquaphor 7%, La Roche-Posay 21%, e.l.f. 12%; Sticky or greasy: Aquaphor 1%, La Roche-Posay 2%, e.l.f. 9%; Small or ran out fast: Aquaphor 0%, La Roche-Posay 8%, e.l.f. 9%; Disliked flavor or scent: Aquaphor 0%, La Roche-Posay 4%, e.l.f. 8%; Packaging problem: Aquaphor 1%, La Roche-Posay 9%, e.l.f. 2%.
Chart by THE BEAUTY READ, drawn from our own counts of the Ulta reviews listed above.

Aquaphor lip balm drew the fewest complaints

Aquaphor's listing says the Lip Repair Stick relieves dryness and soothes chapped, cracked lips, with shea butter and jojoba oil, and calls it a fragrance-free lip balm. We link the value pack of two 0.17 oz sticks, shipped and sold by Amazon.com. [A1]

Across 204 usable Ulta reviews of the Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 111 (54%) said it moisturized, 52 (25%) liked the texture, 28 (14%) said it healed chapped or cracked lips, 24 (12%) said it lasted and 20 (10%) would buy it again. Complaints were rare: 14 (7%) said it did not hydrate or wore off, and only 10 (5%) gave one or two stars, the fewest of the three. [R-ULT-AQU]

Of 22 reviewers who used it in cold or dry weather, 18 said it moisturized. [R-ULT-AQU]

See Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 oz on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens the two-stick value pack (0.17 oz each) shipped and sold by Amazon.com.

Good fit for Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 oz if you want a plain, fragrance-free balm that drew the most moisture praise and fewest complaints in these reviews.

Check the current price on Amazon ↗ (paid link)

La Roche-Posay lip balm: most healing praise, most low ratings

La Roche-Posay's listing describes Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 as a light, non-greasy lip treatment for dry to extra dry lips that helps repair the skin barrier by locking in moisture, with shea butter. We link the tube shipped and sold by Amazon.com. [A2]

In 172 usable Ulta reviews of La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5, 69 (40%) said it moisturized, 38 (22%) said it healed chapped or cracked lips, 30 (17%) would buy it again, 23 (13%) said it lasted and 23 (13%) liked the texture. On the other side, 36 (21%) said it did not hydrate or wore off, 16 (9%) had a packaging problem, 13 (8%) said it was small for the price or ran out fast, 7 (4%) disliked the scent or taste, and 37 (22%) gave one or two stars. [R-ULT-LRP]

Of 11 reviewers who said they have sensitive lips or skin, 7 said it felt gentle. [R-ULT-LRP]

See La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens the Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 tube shipped and sold by Amazon.com.

e.l.f. Squeeze Me, the tinted lip balm reviewers rebuy

e.l.f.'s listing describes Squeeze Me as a moisturizing balm with a sheer tint, made with shea butter, hyaluronic acid and goji berry, in a squeeze tube with an applicator. If you searched for the elf lip balm, this is it; we link the Strawberry option, 0.21 oz, shipped and sold by Amazon.com. [A3]

In 273 usable Ulta reviews of e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, 112 (41%) liked the flavor or scent, 88 (32%) said it moisturized, 71 (26%) called it a good value, 65 (24%) would buy it again and 35 (13%) liked the tint or shine. Complaints: 33 (12%) said it did not hydrate or wore off, 24 (9%) found it sticky, 24 (9%) said it was small for the price or ran out fast, 21 (8%) disliked the flavor or scent and 10 (4%) described irritation. [R-ULT-ELF]

See e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens the Strawberry option (0.21 oz) shipped and sold by Amazon.com.

Lip balm for chapped lips, and how each one feels

Shopping for a lip balm for chapped lips? Of reviewers who said they bought it for very dry, chapped or cracked lips, 23 of 43 for La Roche-Posay and 8 of 15 for Aquaphor said it healed them, and only 5 of those 43 La Roche-Posay reviewers said it did not hydrate or wore off (e.l.f. had 9 such reviewers, too few to compare). [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-AQU]

On feel, 25% of Aquaphor, 19% of e.l.f. and 13% of La Roche-Posay reviewers liked the texture. 9% of e.l.f. reviewers found it sticky, against 2% for La Roche-Posay and 1% for Aquaphor. For a tinted lip balm, 13% of e.l.f. reviewers liked the sheer color or shine. [R-ULT-AQU] [R-ULT-LRP] [R-ULT-ELF]

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission when you buy through these paid links.

Ready to choose?

Each button opens the exact option we checked. Pick by what matters most to you: fewest complaints, help for very dry lips, or flavor and a sheer tint.

Most moisture praise, fewest complaints: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick on Amazon (paid link)

Most healing praise, most low ratings: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast on Amazon (paid link)

Most flavor, value and repurchase talk: e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm on Amazon (paid link)

Sellers at our check (October 26, 2026): Amazon.com, Amazon.com, Amazon.com. Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, 2 x 0.17 oz: This link opens the two-stick value pack (0.17 oz each) shipped and sold by Amazon.com. La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5: This link opens the Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 tube shipped and sold by Amazon.com. e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry: This link opens the Strawberry option (0.21 oz) shipped and sold by Amazon.com. Offers change, so confirm the option and seller on Amazon before you order.

Keep reading

  • Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask, Glowy Balm and Glaze Craze
  • Peel-off lip stain: Sacheu, Wonderskin and Maybelline
  • Best dry shampoo: Living Proof, K18 and Batiste

Frequently asked questions

What is the best lip balm for very dry lips in these reviews?

The best lip balm depends on what you need. Aquaphor drew the most moisture praise (54% of 204 usable Ulta reviews) and the fewest complaints. La Roche-Posay drew the most healed-lips praise (22% of 172) but also the most did-not-hydrate or wore-off complaints (21%), while 7% of Aquaphor reviewers said so.

Is Aquaphor lip balm worth it?

Reviewers were largely positive: 54% of 204 usable Ulta reviews said the Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick moisturized and only 5% gave one or two stars, the fewest of the three. Note that 69 of the 290 Aquaphor reviews we read said the balm was free or a sample, and we left those out, along with 14 other reviews from that July 2025 wave.

Does La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 help chapped lips?

About 1 in 5 reviewers said so: 22% of 172 usable Ulta reviews said it healed chapped or cracked lips, the most of the three, and 23 of 43 reviewers with very dry lips said it healed them. Still, 21% said it did not hydrate or wore off, and 22% gave one or two stars.

Is the e.l.f. Squeeze Me lip balm moisturizing?

Some reviewers said so: 32% of 273 usable Ulta reviews said it moisturized, fewer than Aquaphor (54%) or La Roche-Posay (40%). Its reviewers talked more about flavor (41%), value (26%) and buying it again (24%), and 9% found it sticky.

Which lip balm is fragrance free?

Of these three, Aquaphor's listing says the Lip Repair Stick is fragrance free, and none of its usable reviews complained about scent or taste. 4% of La Roche-Posay reviewers disliked its scent or taste, and 41% of e.l.f. reviewers liked its flavor or scent while 8% disliked it.

THE FINAL CHECK

Is this the right choice for your routine?

THE SHORT ANSWER

Most moisture praise, fewest complaints: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick (54% said moisturizing; 7% said it did not hydrate or wore off). Most healed-lips praise and most low ratings: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 (22% healed; 21% did not hydrate or wore off; 22% one or two stars). Most flavor, value and repurchase talk: e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm (41% liked the flavor, 24% would buy again; 9% sticky).

THINK TWICE IF

You want the fewest letdowns: 21% of La Roche-Posay reviewers said it did not hydrate or wore off and 22% gave one or two stars. You dislike flavored or tacky balms: 8% of e.l.f. reviewers disliked the flavor or scent and 9% found it sticky. You go through balm fast: 9% of e.l.f. and 8% of La Roche-Posay reviewers said it was small for the price or ran out fast.

We separate brand claims from customer experiences. We check shopping links and disclose when a purchase may earn us a commission.

OUR SOURCES & HOW WE REVIEW

What we checked.

See where the information comes from and how we reached our take. Brand claims, customer experiences, and our interpretation are identified separately.

  1. Amazon: Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick, Value Pack 2 x 0.17 oz (paid link). Checked October 26, 2026 with a US delivery address: title, bullets, option (2 sticks, 0.17 oz each), seller (shipped and sold by Amazon.com).
  2. Amazon: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5 (paid link). Checked October 26, 2026 with a US delivery address: title, bullets, seller (shipped and sold by Amazon.com).
  3. Amazon: e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, Strawberry (paid link). Checked October 26, 2026 with a US delivery address: title, bullets, option (Strawberry, 0.21 oz), seller (shipped and sold by Amazon.com).
  4. Ulta: customer reviews page for Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick. 290 reviews read on October 26, 2026 (every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 290 of 2,834 shown, Jan 22, 2025 to Mar 28, 2026). Tallied by THE BEAUTY READ.
  5. Ulta: customer reviews page for La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Lip Balm B5. 291 reviews read on October 26, 2026 (every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 291 of 622 shown, Aug 29, 2023 to May 6, 2026). Tallied by THE BEAUTY READ.
  6. Ulta: customer reviews page for e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm. 285 reviews read on October 26, 2026 (every distinct review Ulta's pages served, 285 of 807 shown, Jul 10, 2024 to Jul 18, 2026). Tallied by THE BEAUTY READ.

About this guide: we did not test these products ourselves. Shares come from the customer reviews we read, not from every review on each site, and describe other people's experiences; the picks follow those patterns and are not a ranking. No review text is reproduced, and Amazon reviews, ratings and prices are not used.

Retailer prices, review totals and product information can change. This article is not medical advice.

How we read reviewsReport a correction

Keep reading

Explore all articles →

More review analyses: Dr.Jart+ moisturizers · LANEIGE lip products · Medicube Zero Pore Pad · UNOVE hair treatment · Korean collagen masks · e.l.f. Halo Glow · ceramide creams for dry skin

Pixi Glow Tonic vs The Ordinary Glycolic Acid: 2,630 Usable Reviews

Pixi Glow Tonic vs The Ordinary Glycolic Acid: 2,630 Usable Reviews

Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere: 517 Usable Reviews

Athena Golden Vanilla vs eos Vanilla Cashmere: 517 Usable Reviews

Does AmLactin Help With Keratosis Pilaris? 1,842 Ulta & Target Reviews

Does AmLactin Help With Keratosis Pilaris? 1,842 Ulta & Target Reviews

THE INDEPENDENT BEAUTY EDIT

THE BEAUTY READ

Less guessing. More good questions. Beauty reviews that help you decide what belongs in your routine.

Explore our reviews →
EXPLORE
ArticlesSkincareSuncareMakeupHairBodyBeauty ToolsBeauty IntelligenceBeauty Now
THE PUBLICATION
AboutContactPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service
© 2026 THE BEAUTY READ. MORE CONTEXT, BETTER CHOICES.INDEPENDENT BEAUTY REVIEWS
ArticlesAboutContact
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service
© 2026 THE BEAUTY READ. All rights reserved.