Best Tubing Mascara? 750 Sephora Reviews of tarte, Clinique, Blinc

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links marked “paid link” earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never decide which product we recommend. Offers and sellers change, so check the shade, size and seller on the product page before you buy.

Review-analysis guide: 750 customer reviews read on Sephora (October 22, 2026), sorted and counted by us; product details from brand and retailer pages checked October 22, 2026. We paraphrase patterns and never copy reviews. Results are patterns that customers described and we counted.

By The Beauty Read · Checked October 22, 2026 · AI-assisted research and editing · Contains Amazon affiliate links

For length, tarte tartelette tubing mascara (paid link) leads our 750 Sephora reviews: 29% say it lengthens, though 14% report flaking. For no smudging, Clinique Lash Power (paid link) does best: 44% say it doesn't smudge, including 35 of 41 who say they have hooded or oily lids or that mascara usually smudges on them. Blinc Original (paid link), which Sephora calls the original tube technology mascara, is a think-twice: 47% gave it one star.

What is tubing mascara, and which one should you buy?

A tubing mascara does not paint lashes the way a regular formula does. Clinique's Amazon listing says its polymers form a tube around each lash, tarte's Sephora description says tiny tubes wrap each lash, and Blinc's says the tubes slide off with plenty of warm water and gentle pressure instead of a remover. We compared three sold by Amazon.com in its Luxury Beauty store: tarte tartelette tubing mascara, Clinique Lash Power Mascara Long-Wearing Formula and Blinc Original Tubing Mascara. [A2] [S1] [S3]

They answer different needs. Of 248 usable tarte reviews, 71 (29%) say their lashes looked longer. Of 248 for Clinique Lash Power, 110 (44%) say it doesn't smudge and 86 (35%) say it lasts all day. Of 250 for Blinc Original, 117 (47%) gave it one star and 64 (26%) say the formula changed. [R-SEP-TA] [R-SEP-CL] [R-SEP-BL]

How we read 750 Sephora reviews

For each mascara we read the 250 newest English Sephora reviews that do not carry Sephora's Incentivized flag. For tarte they run from July 2025 to October 2026, and we set aside 81 Incentivized reviews in that window without reading them (2 more for Blinc). Clinique's run from September 2019 to May 2026, with 222 of the usable ones from 2020 to 2024. Blinc's run from November 2019 to February 2025, the newest Blinc review in Sephora's feed; we did not confirm that Blinc is still sold at Sephora. We also set aside 4 Sephora employee reviews and 12 in other languages. [R-SEP-TA] [R-SEP-CL] [R-SEP-BL]

We then dropped 1 review from someone who had not used it yet, 1 from someone who only tried a points-reward mini, 1 about a mascara bought for someone else and 1 not in English. That leaves 746 usable: 248 tarte, 248 Clinique and 250 Blinc. Every share below is out of the usable reviews for the mascara named. [R-SEP-TA] [R-SEP-CL] [R-SEP-BL]

Urban Decay Tube Job and Too Faced Ribbon Wrapped Lash are not here because most of their Sephora reviews carry the Incentivized flag (2,959 of 3,101 and 877 of 1,025). MERIT and KVD tubing mascaras had only third-party sellers on Amazon at our check, and Thrive Causemetics is not sold at Sephora.

tarte tartelette is the length pick

Sephora calls tartelette a micro-tubing mascara with shea butter, castor oil and carnauba wax, and Amazon's listing describes a comb brush with 296 bristles. We link the full size in black, sold by Amazon.com. [S1] [A1]

Length is what reviewers notice: 71 of 248 (29%) say their lashes looked longer and 21 (8%) mention volume. It is loved by 104 (42%), and 62 (25%) say it comes off easily with warm water, against 22 (9%) who found it hard to remove. [R-SEP-TA]

The complaints are about wear. Thirty-four (14%) report flaking, the most of the three, and 32 (13%) found it clumpy or spidery. Twenty (8%) say it smudged and 14 (6%) say their curl dropped. One in four (63) gave it one or two stars. [R-SEP-TA]

See tarte tartelette tubing mascara (full size, black) on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens the full-size tartelette tubing mascara in black; brown and a travel size are separate options, so check before you buy.

Clinique Lash Power: the no-smudge pick for smudge-prone lids

Sephora's product description says Lash Power lengthens, lasts up to 24 hours through rain, sweat, humidity and tears, and comes off with warm water; it is ophthalmologist-tested, safe for contact lens wearers and fragrance-free. We link Black Onyx, sold by Amazon.com. [S2] [A2]

Staying put is its strength: 110 of 248 usable reviewers (44%) say it doesn't smudge, 86 (35%) say it lasts all day and 45 (18%) say it doesn't flake. Forty-one say they have hooded or oily lids or that most mascaras smudge on them, and 35 of those 41 say Lash Power did not. It is loved by 116 (47%), the most of the three. [R-SEP-CL]

The look is quieter: 51 (21%) describe natural, defined lashes and 34 (14%) mention length, while 17 (7%) found it too subtle. Twenty-six (10%) report flaking. Most of these reviews are from 2020 to 2024, so newer batches are less represented. [R-SEP-CL]

See Clinique Lash Power Mascara Long-Wearing Formula (Black Onyx) on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens Lash Power in Black Onyx; Dark Chocolate is on the same page, so check the shade before you buy.

Blinc Original, the 'original' tubing mascara, is now a think-twice

Sephora's product description calls Blinc Original the original tube technology mascara, removed only with plenty of warm water and gentle pressure. We link black, sold by Amazon.com. [S3] [A3]

The reviews we read are hard on it: 117 of 250 (47%) gave it one star, and 64 (26%) say the formula changed. Ninety-two (37%) found it too subtle and 81 (32%) say it went on clumpy or stuck lashes together. Half of the formula-change reports (32 of 64) are from 2020, but the low ratings continued: 81 of the 121 reviews from 2021 to 2024 gave one or two stars. [R-SEP-BL]

Its fans like the classic tubing traits: 58 (23%) say it doesn't smudge and 52 (21%) say it comes off easily. Forty-six (18%) still love it. [R-SEP-BL]

See Blinc Original Tubing Mascara (black) on Amazon (paid link) · This link opens Blinc Original in black; dark brown and Blinc's other mascaras sit on the same page, so check the version before you buy.

How does tubing mascara wear and feel? Removal, flakes and clumps

Easy removal is the promise, and about a quarter of reviewers confirm it: 25% for tarte, 28% for Clinique and 21% for Blinc say it came off easily with warm water. Fewer disagree, but the share is steady across the three: 9%, 8% and 9% found it hard to remove. [R-SEP-TA] [R-SEP-CL] [R-SEP-BL]

Flakes are the other side of the tubes: 14% of tarte, 10% of Clinique and 7% of Blinc reviewers report bits on their face during the day. Clumping is mostly a Blinc complaint (32%), against 13% for tarte and 7% for Clinique. [R-SEP-TA] [R-SEP-CL] [R-SEP-BL]

Which tubing mascara to buy, and when to skip it

If mascara usually smudges on you, start with Clinique Lash Power: it has the most no-smudge reports and the fewest smudging complaints (2%) in our count. If you want lashes that look longer, tarte tartelette had the most length reports, but skip it if flakes on your cheeks bother you. [R-SEP-CL] [R-SEP-TA]

Buy Blinc Original only if you already know and like its subtle, natural look. For a first tubing mascara, the reviews we read point to the other two. [R-SEP-BL]

Keep reading

• Best Korean concealer: 1,072 customer reviews
• Best vanilla perfume: 750 Sephora reviews
• Best shampoo for curly hair: 502 Sephora reviews

Frequently asked questions

What is tubing mascara?

A mascara whose polymers wrap each lash in tiny tubes instead of painting it, as the brands describe it. The tubes are meant to resist smudging; Clinique and Blinc say they come off with warm water, and Blinc adds gentle pressure.

What is the best tubing mascara?

It depends on what you need. In the 750 Sephora reviews we read, tarte tartelette had the most length reports (29%), Clinique Lash Power had the most no-smudge reports (44%), and Blinc Original drew one-star ratings from 47%.

Is tubing mascara good for hooded eyes?

Clinique Lash Power had the most such reports in our count: 35 of the 41 reviewers who say they have hooded or oily lids or that mascara usually smudges on them say it did not smudge. Blinc Original's figure was 19 of 24, a smaller group.

Does tubing mascara flake?

Some reviewers say so: 14% of tarte tartelette, 10% of Clinique Lash Power and 7% of Blinc Original reviewers report flaking during the day. For tarte, flaking reports outnumber no-flake reports (34 against 21); for Clinique it is the other way round, with 45 saying it did not flake against 26 who saw flakes.

How do you remove tubing mascara?

Clinique and Blinc say warm water, and Blinc adds gentle pressure; tarte's Amazon listing calls its formula easy to remove. About a quarter of reviewers agree it came off easily (21% to 28%), while 8% to 9% found it hard to remove.